top of page
Wallpaper PC5.jpg
Search

The Merzian naive calculation: Why only a fool can understand Switzerland so wrongly

Oct 9
2 min read

Updated: Oct 11

Friedrich Merz has once again reached deep into the box of economic wisdom during the ZDF summer interview.


 The result is a statistical masterpiece of the highest order: the Swiss allegedly work a full 200 hours per year more than the supposedly lazy Germans.


A wonderfully simple number to guilt-trip the domestic population.


Yet when looking at the facts, mainly one thing remains of the Chancellor's rhetoric: an embarrassing display of blatant ignorance.


  1. The Chancellor's thesis

    Claim by Friedrich Merz: "The Swiss work 200 hours a year more than we do."


    Goal of the statement: Moral arming for longer working hours and the reduction of social standards in Germany through blind Switzerland romanticism.


  2. The scientific reality check

    Anyone who reduces the complex working worlds of two countries to a pub-talk one-liner has either not understood OECD methodology—or is deliberately relying on selective perception.


Parameter

Switzerland

Germany

The scientific reality

Full-time hours / week (2025)

42.5 hrs.

38.4 hrs.

Merz's cherry-pick: From this alone, the difference of ~200 hours is calculated.

All employed persons / week

35.2 hrs.

34.3 hrs.

The overall average: Including part-time, the gap shrinks to under 1 hour per week.

Real annual difference



42 to 50 hours instead of the claimed 200 hours.


Part-time rate

42%

Lower

The high Swiss full-time norm massively shifts work into unpaid care work.


Retirement entry & taxes

Earlier / Lower

Later / Higher

The Swiss earn more, often pay fewer taxes and duties, and retire earlier.



The methodological fallacies in detail

 

  1. The cherry-picking phenomenon: The 200 hours celebrated by Merz exist only in a world where there are exclusively full-time workers. If part-time employees and actual working lifetime are factored in, the Swiss lead shrinks to a meager 42 to 50 hours a year.


  2. Hidden care work: Experts explicitly warn against praising the Swiss model as a role model. The full-time norm there by no means leads to gigantic leaps in productivity per hour, but simply shifts childcare and eldercare into the unpaid private sphere—predominantly onto women.


  3. Quality of life instead of drudgery: Swiss citizens enjoy higher wage levels, lower tax and contribution burdens, and retire earlier. Those who earn more and stop working earlier can simply afford a higher quality of life. A connection that the Chancellor conveniently ignores in his debate on performance.


  4. The Scientific conclusion


The OECD itself warns against uncritical comparisons of international annual working hours, as collection methods and surveyed groups vary significantly.


Friedrich Merz's Switzerland comparison proves in a reality check to be a classic case of political half-truth: anyone who ignores part-time rates, retirement age, productivity per hour, and unpaid care work is not conducting serious economic policy.


Instead of an honest debate on a better work-life balance for families, the Chancellor presents convenient fallacies based on selective numbers.


 
 
 

Comments


Cirfcle1.png
Background tran.png
FaktenBlick9.png

Nachrichten auf dem Prüfstand

bottom of page