The doomed federal chancellor
Updated: Oct 11
Friedrich Merz is politically dead, yet an elegant, dignified exit is conspicuously lacking on the political stage. The audience has no choice but to take in the full, unvarnished reality of Chancellor Merz's tenure.

Since late 2024, the political press has been serving the public a endless stream of fairy tales about this man.
Commentators prematurely celebrated Merz as the great savior of the center-right camp who would single-handedly correct three years of failed Green energy policies.
His inner circle sold him as an international virtuoso and Europe's primary "Trump whisperer," someone who would effortlessly convince Washington to maintain support for Ukraine. Conspiracy theories, on the other hand, branded him a shadowy BlackRock strategist who would immediately pull economic policy strings in the Chancellery.
Predictably, not a single one of these narratives held up against reality. Merz simply proved to be what he had always been: an ineffective actor, a stubborn political figure with no visible blueprint, no strategy, and no genuine ambitions—aside from moving into the Chancellery itself.
He is merely steering the next phase of German political decay, a process in which each successive head of state sets new standards for institutional absurdity.
In direct comparison, Merz makes Angela Merkel look like a master political strategist, while he successfully spares Olaf Scholz's turbulent cabinet from going down in history as the absolute peak of modern German political chaos.
Merz shines with popularity ratings that would put any pollster to sleep: a pitiful 14% of voters are convinced that he belongs in this post. His authority within his own party has eroded so thoroughly that even an attempt to reassign an unpopular deputy secretary general ended in another public humiliation.
At least twenty CDU/CSU MPs have already openly refused obedience on the tax reforms negotiated with the Social Democrats, while new rebellions in the committees threaten to capsize the upcoming budget vote in November.
To complete the chaos, the leadership of the Parliamentary Group for Medium-Sized Business (Mittelstand) is earnest in demanding the dismissal of Social Democratic Labor Minister Bärbel Bas—a move that would blow up the coalition on the spot.
Public appearances have turned into a torture for him; demonstrators regularly drown out his speeches. Subsequent election candidates carefully avoid appearing at his side, although distance offers little protection against the drag of his poll numbers.
Polls indicate that the CDU is heading toward a historic low next Sunday in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, coupled with serious concern over whether the party will even clear the 5% threshold for the state parliament.
Following the setback in Saxony-Anhalt, the situation in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania promises an even steeper crash. Even established party figures are keeping their distance. For a crisis meeting at the Konrad Adenauer House in Berlin—intended to demonstrate resolve following the results in Saxony-Anhalt—nobody appeared at all except for a single CDU state premier. Merz was left addressing empty chairs.
Later appearances did little to reassure critics. At a post-election press conference, he rambled vaguely about better "emotional communication" and unexpectedly lashed out against his own deputy parliamentary group leader.
Days later in the Bundestag, Merz threw his prepared manuscript overboard to deliver an off-the-cuff speech against the Alternative for Germany—curiously mocking the party for securing only a 44% vote share and accusing its members of engaging in "ethnic cleansing" under the banner of remigration.
Given his severely damaged position, party insiders continuously feed journalists details regarding various plans for a leadership change.
Many within the party give his chancellorship only weeks, betting that a new face could halt the decline in the polls. Recent surveys show the AfD at a record high of 30%, while the CDU/CSU trails behind at a miserable 20%.
The pressure for a change comes primarily from state premiers whose regional electoral prospects are directly threatened by headwinds from Berlin.
Yet a chancellor is not easily ousted. Merz shows no signs of stepping down, nor has anyone brought a vote of confidence into play. Rock-solid in his conviction of his own performance, Merz has no intention of changing course.
This leaves the constructive vote of no confidence as the sole constitutional tool—an option the CDU shies away from. The current strategy relies on state leaders persuading the chancellor to step down voluntarily, backed by the subtle threat of an ouster vote to force a handover to a designated successor.
However, the search for a consensus candidate presents its own hurdles, as the party cannot afford a protracted power struggle.
While commentators like to point to Hendrik Wüst, the moderate state premier of North Rhine-Westphalia, he positions himself to the left of most CDU MPs. His ambitions face quiet resistance from CSU leader Markus Söder.
Conversely, the prospect of a Chancellor Söder meets tough reservations: the CSU has never provided the chancellor, and CDU traditionalists steadfastly refuse to hand power over to the Bavarian sister party.
Alternative figures such as Hesse's State Premier Boris Rhein are occasionally mentioned, but remain purely speculative.
Fundamentally, swapping personnel does not resolve the Union's structural problems. The self-imposed firewall (Brandmauer) against the AfD forces the party into coalitions with left-wing partners and parks it in a difficult political no-man's-land. Left-wing voters migrate to established left-wing parties, while the protest camp turns to the AfD.
Improved communication would be a quick upgrade, but rhetoric alone cannot resolve substantive contradictions.
A successor might negotiate more skillfully behind closed doors, but tactical tricks hit their limit as long as mathematical options remain locked behind the firewall.
Without the threat of alternative alliances, the CDU remains unable to dictate terms to its current partners.
Thus, the current government drags itself along for lack of alternatives—a dynamic that keeps Merz in office for now. As long as the standstill persists, the country remains tied to a leadership that can neither organize stable majorities nor pass essential legislation.







Comments