Refusal to obey orders: The supreme duty of the citizen in uniform, the government gets breathless
Updated: Oct 11
On July 20, 2026, around 240 fresh recruits lined up once again in Berlin's Bendlerblock to stand at attention during the ceremonial pledge.

As usual, the occasion marking the 82nd anniversary of the Stauffenberg assassination attempt was draped in plenty of solemn, state-supporting tinsel.
But because a touch of cultural celebrity on the speaker list is always good for the image, writer and Peace Prize winner Navid Kermani was permitted to step up to the microphone this time.
What followed was a wonderful object lesson in how quickly nerves wear thin in the government quarter—and how reliably the public broadcasters of ARD and ZDF deploy as a PR fire brigade.
The faux pas of remembering the Basic Law
Kermani committed an unheard-of audacity on stage: he actually took the concept of Innere Führung (leadership and civic education) seriously.
Before the assembled troops, he reminded the young soldiers that the Basic Law stands above any march order. He spoke about the duty to think critically, about the right to conscientious objection in cases of conscience, and the historical lesson that refusing to obey unconstitutional orders is not a test of courage, but the supreme duty of a citizen in uniform.
Essentially the exact textbook foundation upon which the Bundeswehr was founded after 1945. But in present-day Berlin, where rearmament, war-readiness, and seamless obedience are once again part of polite etiquette, such tones act like sand in freshly oiled gears.
The fact that an guest of honor explained to recruits that they are not order-receiving automatons understandably did not fit the Ministry of Defense strategists' parade rhetoric at all.
ARD and ZDF as faithful loudspeakers of power
Where the government is miffed, the broadcasting institutions of ARD and ZDF are famously not far behind to supply the appropriate background noise. Instead of framing Kermani's words as a constitutionally sound reminder of the limits of the military, the managed outrage machinery immediately ran at full throttle.
With the usual solemn expressions, Kermani's speech was promptly polished up on screen into a "scandal".
After all, standard playbook logic functions splendidly: politicians are annoyed, and public broadcasting dutifully takes on the task of shifting the mood in line with Berlin's government hallways.
Instead of questioning the substantive core of the address, fee-payers are drilled to believe that critical nuances at a military ceremony border on subversion of the state.
ARD and ZDF have once again proven where their coverage's true allegiance lies: when the government sulks because someone invokes the spirit of conscientious decision-making, state broadcasters reliably whip up sentiment. The fact that the historical lesson of July 20 degenerates into mere scenery in the process is something broadcasting headquarters are evidently all too happy to accept.







Comments