From Constitutional Law to Political Farce: Ten Hours of Democracy in Thuringia
Updated: Oct 11
For almost ten hours, the Thuringian state parliament debated a possible ban on the AfD Lawyers; constitutional scholars and expert witnesses grappled with the great questions of constitutional law.

And apparently, that still wasn't quite enough expertise. So Hape Kerkeling was invited to join in.
By evening, things had become genuinely funny—entirely unintentionally.
There are days when a parliamentary hearing writes its own satire. Thursday in the Thuringian state parliament was clearly one of them.
The question on the agenda was no small matter: should Thuringia support proceedings to ban the AfD? The proposal came from the Left Party, which wants the state government to press the federal government and the Bundesrat, Germany's upper house of parliament, to initiate proceedings under Article 21(2) of the German Constitution.
In other words, a serious business. Constitutional law. Democracy. Banning political parties. When the stakes are that high, apparently there's no need to be too fussy about whom you invite as an expert.
When Hape Kerkeling Becomes a Political Expert
And so, alongside lawyers and constitutional scholars, Hape Kerkeling found himself among the political experts. Yes, that Hape Kerkeling. The comedian who made Germany laugh as Horst Schlämmer impersonated Queen Beatrix and demonstrated with his legendary Hurz! Sketch that even the art world could be taken for a ride.
Now he was weighing in on constitutional politics. One might say that when ten hours of constitutional law aren't enough, a democracy occasionally needs someone who knows how to recognize an absurd situation.
Whether Kerkeling could actually contribute anything to the legal assessment of the requirements for banning a political party is, of course, another question entirely.
Still, the event had at least acquired an expert in a discipline that would play a major role that evening: political farce. And it wasn't long before the entertainment began.
The Plan Was to Keep Things Entirely Professional
The parliamentary committee on legal affairs had invited lawyers, experts and other guests to examine whether the constitutional requirements for banning the AfD might be met.
All very sober. All serious. All perfectly constitutional.
And then Ulrich Vosgerau took the floor.
The constitutional lawyer discussed the consequences of a successful party ban and used a phrase that probably generated headlines faster than all his legal arguments combined:
“The total annihilation of a political party.” Suddenly, the phrase party ban had acquired some serious political explosive power.
“What exactly are you trying to say with that?” demanded Wolfgang Weißkopf, a CDU member of the state parliament.
His objection was that Vosgerau's wording made a party ban sound like a weapon designed to wipe out a political rival completely. The purpose of such proceedings, Weißkopf argued, was to protect the Constitution.
A reasonable point. One might have thought that would settle the matter.
But Vosgerau had other ideas. He retorted that he, too, had no idea “what was going on in your head” and suggested that, given the late hour, the CDU politician's reasoning had become relatively muddled.
And then came the line of the evening:
“No one can doubt that proceedings to ban a political party are aimed at its total annihilation.”
There it was again. Total annihilation.
Three Words, and Ten Hours of Constitutional Law Suddenly Don't Matter
In legal terms, “total annihilation” is not a technical expression. Politically, however, it is a rather explosive way of describing what a successful party ban actually means: the party is outlawed and removed from political competition.
You can regard this as a necessary safeguard for democratic order. You can warn against the far-reaching consequences of such a measure. But one point is difficult to dispute:
A party ban is not a political parking ticket.
It is one of the most severe measures the state can take against a political party. That is precisely why the debate is so charged.
And Then Came the Call to “Dial Down the Rhetoric”
The response from the room was immediate. “What on earth are you talking about?”
Eventually, the chair had to intervene and urge everyone to “dial down the rhetoric.”
Picture the scene. For ten hours, politicians and legal experts had been discussing how a democracy can defend itself. And at some point, the chair had to remind them that a democracy prepared to defend itself must apparently also defend itself against its own choice of words.
Perhaps this would have been the perfect moment for Hape Kerkeling. Horst Schlämmer would probably have offered just one response: “I'm running for office!”
The Real Dispute, However, Is Deadly Serious
As entertaining as the verbal sparring may have been, the question at its heart is no laughing matter.
Supporters of a ban see it as a last-resort instrument of a democracy capable of defending itself. If the demanding constitutional requirements are met, the state can exclude a political party from the democratic contest.
Critics point to precisely that consequence. Once you ban a party, you are no longer simply fighting it politically. You are ending its political existence.
That is why the constitutional hurdles are so high. And that is also why a failed attempt to ban a party would mean more than losing a vote. It could have serious political and constitutional consequences.
And What About the CDU?
One thing is particularly interesting about what happened after the big confrontation: what didn't happen.
The Thuringian CDU did not suddenly announce its support for banning the AfD. Weißkopf did not commit himself to such a position.
Instead, the CDU wants to examine whether the constitutional requirements for a ban are actually met.
The hearing produced new arguments, but there is still no final position. That is considerably less dramatic than “total annihilation”.
It is also probably much closer to what a hearing of this kind is supposed to achieve.
Ten Hours Later, One Thing Sticks in the Mind
Almost ten hours of deliberations. Lawyers. Constitutional scholars. Experts. Politicians. And Hape Kerkeling.
Then a furious argument over whether banning a political party protects democracy or destroys a political opponent.
And in the end, three words overshadowed practically everything else: “The total annihilation of a political party.”
Perhaps that was the real punchline of the day. A hearing intended to provide constitutional clarity produced political headlines instead. A session on democracy's ability to defend itself ended with a plea for everyone to tone down their language. And somewhere in the middle of it all sat Hape Kerkeling.
You could hardly have written a better script. There is, however, one thing we should not forget amid all the satire: banning a political party is not a comedy show.
It is a constitutional instrument with enormous consequences. And that is precisely why it deserves serious debate.
Still, after ten hours in the Thuringian state parliament, one conclusion seems unavoidable:
If democracy is theater, then this was one hell of a show.







Comments