top of page
Wallpaper PC5.jpg
Search

Friedrich Merz, Ukraine’s chancellor – Germany, the cash cow of nations

Oct 21
6 min read

Billions for foreign countries, austerity at home – and anyone who wants to leave Germany gets one last bill on the way out.


Some governments try to keep their citizens at home by giving them something worth staying for: affordable energy, functioning infrastructure, secure pensions, and a viable economic future.


Friedrich Merz’s government appears to have a different strategy. If you want to leave Germany, you should at least stop at the cashier’s desk first.


Welcome to a country where the government not only wants to know what its citizens earn but, under certain circumstances, also wants a cut when they decide to build their economic future somewhere else. Enter the exit tax.


Under specific conditions, shareholders can be taxed on increases in the value of certain company holdings as though they had sold them, even when no sale has taken place. The money may not even be in the bank account yet, but the taxman is already knocking at the door. You are free to say goodbye. Just make sure you can afford the farewell.


Billions for Ukraine, the bill for Germany

While German businesses struggle with high costs, infrastructure crumbles in many places, and ordinary citizens face mounting financial pressure, the government likes to present Germany as a generous international benefactor.


Substantial support for Ukraine is mobilized, while domestic reforms, tax relief, and financial breathing room remain subjects of endless political wrangling.


Of course, international responsibility and support for Ukraine deserve serious debate. But so do the priorities of a government and the explanations it owes its own citizens. When billions can be mobilized for international commitments, every euro suddenly seems to require a lengthy political struggle if the aim is to ease the burden at home.


Maria Zakharova, spokeswoman for Russia’s Foreign Ministry, has mockingly referred to Friedrich Merz as “Ukraine’s chancellor.” It is a political jab from a Russian government representative, not a neutral description.


Yet the debate behind the insult cannot simply be dismissed. What impression does the German public get when its government appears determined to deliver on international commitments while domestic problems are repeatedly pushed back to the next round of reforms?


Perhaps Berlin should explain why substantial sums can regularly be found for geopolitical ambitions, while financial constraints suddenly dominate every discussion about helping people at home. Germany is apparently expected to take responsibility for just about everything. When it comes to its own citizens, however, generosity seems to have its limits.

Leaving Germany? Please pay at the door

The exit tax fits rather uncomfortably into this picture. It does not apply to every German who emigrates. It primarily affects people who hold certain substantial interests in corporations and meet specific legal conditions. But for entrepreneurs and shareholders, the consequences can be considerable.


Under the rules, certain increases in value are treated for tax purposes as though the shares had been sold. That means taxes may become due on gains that have not actually been realized. The wealth remains tied up in the business, while the tax bill is already sitting on the table. For anyone without sufficient liquid assets, this can create a serious financial problem.


You might think a government determined to strengthen Germany as a business location would first ask why entrepreneurs are considering leaving in the first place. Is it the high cost of doing business? The bureaucracy? The tax burden? The lack of predictability? Or perhaps the prospect of having the taxman hovering over every major economic decision?


Instead of making Germany more attractive, the state maintains a tax mechanism that can produce a bill when certain shareholders move abroad. It almost sounds like a uniquely German farewell ritual: pay taxes for years, decide to start over somewhere else, and then discover that even profits you have not actually collected are of interest to the tax authorities.


Apparently, the domestic cash cow cannot be milked forever. But as long as it is still standing in the barn, the authorities might as well check whether there is anything left to squeeze out before it reaches the gate.

A dark chapter in German history

The history of German exit taxation has a deeply troubling chapter. The Reich Flight Tax (Reichsfluchtsteuer) was introduced in 1931 during the Great Depression, initially to discourage capital flight. After the Nazis seized power, however, it became an instrument of systematic financial plunder, particularly targeting Jewish people who wanted or needed to flee persecution.


The Nazi state took a substantial share of their wealth, making escape financially devastating for many of those it persecuted. The tax became part of a wider system of disenfranchisement, expropriation, and persecution. By 1938, revenue from the Reich Flight Tax had reached enormous levels, with the burden falling overwhelmingly on people persecuted on racial grounds.


Today’s exit tax must not be equated with that system. It operates under different legal rules and is not a racially motivated instrument of confiscation. Historical comparisons require a clear recognition of those differences.


Nevertheless, history demonstrates why state measures linked to leaving one’s own country deserve particularly careful scrutiny. Governments have the right to levy taxes. The question of how far that power should extend is not a minor detail, especially when the burden falls on people seeking to build their economic future elsewhere.

The state needs money – and citizens need trust

Germany introduced the modern form of exit taxation in 1972 through its Foreign Tax Act. Its purpose is to prevent certain taxable gains from escaping German taxation when shareholders move abroad. That is the legislature’s argument. The specific rules, their financial impact, and the available deferral arrangements remain legitimate subjects of debate.


Since 2022, the options for long-term, interest-free tax deferrals have been restricted in many cases. This raises questions about whether the rules are proportionate and whether they unnecessarily complicate economic mobility. Their compatibility with the European Union’s freedom of establishment is also relevant.


A government that wants to strengthen Germany’s economy should therefore ask more than how to secure tax revenue. It should also consider whether its rules discourage investment, complicate business decisions, or reinforce the impression that citizens are primarily a source of revenue.


Economist and financial commentator Markus Krall has also sharply criticized the exit tax in an interview with Ben Unscripted. The important question is not who delivers the most forceful criticism, but whether the existing rules are economically sensible, proportionate, and fair.

Germany first? Then perhaps the Germans, too

Friedrich Merz should be judged by his own political promises. Anyone who wants to restore Germany’s economic strength must explain how businesses will be retained, investment encouraged, and citizens given some financial relief.


A government that takes on substantial international commitments while complaining about financial constraints at home should not be surprised when people start asking uncomfortable questions.


This is not about rejecting every form of foreign aid. It is about priorities, proportionality, and whether the people who actually finance the state still occupy a meaningful place in its calculations.


A country is not an end in itself. The purpose of government is not to keep citizens paying taxes indefinitely while they wait for better times. Nor should it give the impression that it is happy to assume responsibility for the world while viewing its own population primarily through the lens of taxable income and assets.


Perhaps it is time to take a fundamental look at the exit tax and remove unnecessary obstacles. When people and businesses want to leave Germany, the government should first investigate the reasons. Presenting them with another tax bill does not answer that question.


Merz is free to travel abroad, forge alliances, and emphasize Germany’s role in the world. But every now and then, someone should remind him that he is Germany’s chancellor. His political responsibilities include the country whose taxpayers fund his government and whose interests he is supposed to represent.


Billions for foreign countries, austerity at home – and one last handout to the taxman on the way out. It may be a convenient way to protect government revenue. It is hardly a convincing strategy for persuading people and businesses to believe in Germany’s future.


Because when citizens begin to feel that they are expected to be there for everyone except themselves, the government should not start by asking how it can make their departure more expensive.


It should start by asking why they want to leave in the first place.

 
 
 

Comments


Cirfcle1.png
Background tran.png
FaktenBlick9.png

Nachrichten auf dem Prüfstand

bottom of page